Photo: illustrative image created with AI.
Fix it if your pages can be edited, the contact path can be repaired and you control the domain and site. Rebuild when the platform blocks necessary changes, the structure no longer matches the jobs you sell, or the repairs add up to most of a new site anyway. Looking a little old isn't enough reason by itself.
A redesign is more fun to buy, and it can lose a page that has brought in work for years. Test what you have, and get a repair priced, before you approve the bigger job.
Try to hire yourself on a phone
Use your own phone, off the office Wi-Fi, and give yourself a job. Suppose a homeowner needs a panel upgrade before an EV charger goes in. Start from a Google search for your company, then do this:
- Find the page for that job and read whether you do it in that town.
- Tap the number. Check that it rings the phone it should, and see what happens if nobody picks up.
- Send the form with a message marked as a test. Find out who received it and how long it took to surface.
- Ask the person who updates the site to change one sentence on that page while you watch.
Screenshot each failure and write it down in plain words: "form went to a former employee," "upgrade page has no phone button." That list is your repair brief. Repeat the test on your most profitable service and on an older phone if there's one in the truck.
For an aging-in-place contractor, add one more pass. Make the text larger in the phone's settings and see whether the page can still be read and used. Hand it to someone your customers' age and keep quiet while they look for the number.
Plenty of bad websites need a repair
| Symptom | Repair to price first | Sign it's bigger |
|---|---|---|
| Number is buried or won't tap | Change the header and links | The template can't be edited |
| Form leads disappear | Replace the form, its delivery and the backup recipient | Nobody can get into the site |
| The service you want has one line | Write and link a proper page | New pages can't be added or put in the menu |
| Photos and prices are stale | Update the content | Every small edit becomes a paid build |
| Pages are slow on a phone | Resize images and remove scripts you don't use | The platform itself causes the delay and can't be changed |
| Plenty of visits, few inquiries | Check who is visiting and whether the page fits their job | The same fault runs through the whole structure |
The last row catches people out. A plumbing company whose ads send water-heater searches to a general home page has a destination problem, and one good page may settle it. Google's own landing page guidance looks at relevance, useful information, ease of use and whether the page matches what the ad promised. All four can be fixed on one page.
A poor speed score is a clue
Ask which score you're being shown and whether it comes from real visitors or a lab test. Google's targets for real-user experience, called Core Web Vitals, are main content within 2.5 seconds, response to a tap or click under 200 milliseconds and layout shift under 0.1. They do feed its ranking systems, though good scores don't guarantee top rankings.
So a red number justifies finding the cause. If it's a few enormous job photos and an old chat widget, that's a repair. If someone says only a rebuild will cure it, ask them to name what can't be changed on the present platform and why.
Mobile content deserves more urgency. Google indexes and ranks from the mobile version and says it should carry the same content as desktop. If a service description is cut from your mobile pages, put it back.
When a rebuild earns the money
One reason is control. The old provider owns a system you can't export, or logins are gone and can't be recovered. Settle the domain before anything else, using our guide to who owns your website and ad accounts.
Another is a change in the work you sell. An electrical company that used to live on service calls and now wants panels, chargers and generators may need a different menu, different pages and different photos all through the site. Bolting three pages onto the old structure can leave the work it wants least on the home page.
The third is a repair quote that has grown into a rebuild in pieces. A new template, a new form, every page rewritten, a move off dying software: once that's the list, get one price for doing it together and compare. We wouldn't use a promised jump in conversions to break the tie. Nobody can know that number before launch.
If none of these is true, keep the site. Spend what you saved on the weak page, or on whatever happens after the form is sent.
Get both quotes against the same list
Give bidders your failure list and ask for a scoped repair and, only if they recommend it, a rebuild. Each should say which pages are changed, which are removed, who writes the copy, how forms and tracking are tested and who holds every login afterward. Ask the rebuild bidder one extra question: what on this list can't be repaired, and what did you check? The line items are covered in what a contractor website quote should contain.
If you rebuild, carry the old leads across
- Save a list of every current URL, plus traffic, search and lead records for as far back as you have them.
- Mark each page keep, improve, merge or retire.
- Map every changed address to its closest new page.
- Test calls, forms, ad destinations and tracking on the new site before launch.
- Launch, test again and compare with the saved records in the following weeks.
Keep addresses that work. Where one must change, Google recommends a permanent server-side redirect and says to keep it as long as possible, generally at least a year. Don't point all the old pages at the home page. Google warns against that, and a homeowner who wanted generator service shouldn't land there either.
Expect some movement. Google says most pages on a small or medium site can take a few weeks to move, with visibility fluctuating meanwhile. The same guidance suggests making big changes one after another. If you can avoid a new domain, new address structure and new design on the same day, do. Google also suggests bringing in SEO help early when a redesign is planned.
Ads need their own check. Update the destination of every ad and extension. If the account uses AI Max, Google's Final URL expansion is switched on with it. Unless you turn that off, it can send clicks to other pages on the site, including one you meant to retire.
A second look before you sign
Our contractor web design work can mean fixing what you have, and we'll say so when that's the better buy. Request a free 20-minute growth conversation and bring the address of the current site, the failure list from your phone test, any editing problem and the pages or calls you can't afford to lose.
Sources
- Landing page - Google Ads Help, Google. Checked November 22, 2026.
- Understanding Core Web Vitals and Google search results, Google. Checked November 22, 2026.
- Understanding Google Page Experience, Google. Checked November 22, 2026.
- Mobile-first Indexing Best Practices, Google. Checked November 22, 2026.
- Site Moves and Migrations, Google. Checked November 22, 2026.
- Do You Need an SEO? Tips for Hiring an SEO, Google. Checked November 22, 2026.
- How AI Max for Search campaigns works - Google Ads Help, Google. Checked November 22, 2026.
