Photo: illustrative image created with AI.
Find out first whether qualified calls are missing or only untracked, and don't raise the budget while you look. Then follow the clicks from the search to the phone call, in order. The fault could be in targeting, the page, tracking or your own intake, and it could be several at once. A click total can't tell you which.
Put one period's records side by side
Pick a recent period long enough to include some inquiries. Pull the search terms, campaign locations, ad schedule and landing pages from Google Ads, plus the conversions by name. From your own side, get the phone log, form emails and booked jobs for the same dates, with the job addresses. Don't use the caller's area code as the town. Plenty of people keep a cell number when they move.
If real inquiries are in the phone log but absent from the ad report, you may have a tracking problem. If they're absent from both, keep going. If the report shows conversions and the log shows vendors, hang-ups and job seekers, you need to inspect both the searches and what's being counted.
- Read the searches: was this someone hiring?
- Match the job: do you want and offer it?
- Check the place: was the work in your area?
- Open the page: does it repeat the promise and make contact easy?
- Test tracking: what counted as a conversion?
- Follow the call: did someone useful respond?
- Qualify: was it a job you'd send an estimator to?
1. Were the searches from people hiring?
Read the search terms, which are what people typed, rather than the keyword list, which is what you bought. Mark each one as hiring, learning, looking for work, shopping for parts or unclear. An electrician bidding on panel work might find "panel upgrade quote" next to "electrical apprentice jobs" and "how to wire a subpanel."
That mix can happen without anyone adding bad keywords. Broad match is the default, and even exact match can reach searches with the same meaning or intent. If AI Max is on, it can go beyond your keyword list with broad match and keywordless matching. Write down which settings are on before judging the wording.
Add clear misses as negative keywords, and check each before saving it. Negatives don't cover synonyms, or singular and plural versions, so "job" and "jobs" are separate entries. Blocking "cost" because it sounds cheap could also block a homeowner with a real project. The report has gaps too. Google leaves out terms with too little activity, so you won't account for every click.
2. Is it a job you offer and want?
A search can have perfect buying intent and still be wrong for you. An emergency search is no use to a plumber who stops answering at 5. "Water damage repair" might mean extraction tonight, drywall next week or a roof leak you don't touch. For an electrician who wants service upgrades, "electrician near me" will also bring outlets and ceiling fans. That's fine if you like that work.
Write three short lists with your office: wanted, accepted when there's room, never. Compare them with the campaigns and ad wording. If the never list is getting the budget, fix that before touching the website. Our guide to attracting panel and EV charger projects goes further into job-specific campaigns.
3. Where were the jobs?
Open the campaign's location options as well as its town list. Google's default includes people who showed interest in your locations, as well as people in or regularly in them. The narrower option is called Presence. A person in another state looking up Morristown plumbers might matter if they own a house here, or might be no use at all.
Compare with job addresses from your intake notes. Google says location targeting isn't accurate in every case, so a few strays don't prove a bad setup. A pattern of estimates outside the route is worth acting on. Don't shrink the map to a few blocks in response, either. Very small targets may show intermittently or not at all.
4. What happens after the tap?
Do this on a phone, on cellular. Use the address of the page in the ad instead of clicking your live ad and paying for it. An ad for panel upgrades should open on panel upgrades, say which area you cover and show a number you can tap. Submit the form. Find out where it landed and how long it sat there.
Google's description of landing page experience includes useful, relevant information, easy navigation and meeting the expectation the ad set. Also check the destinations people really reached. Turning on AI Max turns on Final URL expansion. Unless you switch that off, it can send clicks to other pages on your site, possibly one about a service you never meant to advertise.
An ugly page isn't automatically the cause. If the phone works, the job is clear and the searches were wrong, a redesign won't save the money.
5. What is Google counting?
Ask for every conversion action by name and whether it's primary or secondary. Primary actions steer automated bidding and secondary ones are for observation. A primary action that fires on a visit to the contact page can train bidding toward people who never called.
Phone tracking has its own traps. Google can count calls over a minimum length you choose, and a supplier can easily talk that long. Tracking taps on a mobile number records the taps, not the calls. If another system records call outcomes, you can import calls so that only the outcomes you choose count. Until then, don't label that column "qualified calls."
Make a test call through each tracked route and watch for it. Remember that your own test is in the totals.
6. What did the caller get?
Match every missed call to a callback, with the time. Look at the hours your ads run against the hours a person can help. A restoration company that advertises all night and sends 2 a.m. callers to voicemail has an intake decision to make, however tidy the campaign is. Either staff it, arrange an answering route or stop advertising those hours.
If a missed-call text is the missing piece, read how text-back works. When calls are answered and still go nowhere, compare marketing with follow-up, stage by stage.
7. Who decides that a lead is qualified?
If the office says the leads are junk and the agency says they're good, they probably don't share a definition. Write one: an offered job, in the area, from someone who can make or influence the decision, with timing you can serve. Then sort the actual calls with both of you in the room. "Bought from someone else" can still be qualified. "Asked the price first" can too.
Be careful with small numbers. Three bad calls in a short test are worth reading, and they don't prove that the channel failed.
When clicks or forms look fake
Google says it doesn't charge for invalid traffic it detects before billing. You can request an investigation, but it only covers the last 60 days and won't tell you whether a particular click was bad. Fake forms are a separate problem. Google's filters run after the ad is shown and can't keep that traffic off your site, so whoever runs the website needs safeguards on the form.
If the bad leads come from Local Services Ads, use a different checklist. That product charges for valid leads instead of clicks, and Google began moving it into Google Ads in August 2026. It opts you into general category searches by default. Google also no longer gives credits for leads labeled job type or area not serviced.
Change one thing, then give it time
Date each change and say what result would make you keep it. After an automated bidding change, Google suggests judging over two conversion cycles or two weeks, whichever is longer. That window starts once bidding has settled on the new goal, and it needs to allow for delayed conversions. A broken phone number doesn't need that wait. Fix it today. If your crews are full or no one can answer, reducing spend is a reasonable first move. The Google Ads budget question comes after these checks.
If you want a second look
Gather the last reporting period, the search terms and a few inquiries your office didn't want, with customer details removed. Then request a free 20-minute growth conversation about your Google Ads. An electrical contractor, a plumber and a restoration company will each start from a different list of wanted searches. We can discuss which check comes first. Without your account and lead records we can't name the cause or promise an improvement.
Sources
- About keyword matching options - Google Ads Help, Google. Checked November 22, 2026.
- About negative keywords - Google Ads Help, Google. Checked November 22, 2026.
- About the search terms report - Google Ads Help, Google. Checked November 22, 2026.
- How AI Max for Search campaigns works - Google Ads Help, Google. Checked November 22, 2026.
- About advanced location options - Google Ads Help, Google. Checked November 22, 2026.
- Target ads to geographic locations - Google Ads Help, Google. Checked November 22, 2026.
- About Smart Bidding learning - Google Ads Help, Google. Checked November 22, 2026.
- About phone call conversion tracking - Google Ads Help, Google. Checked November 22, 2026.
- About conversion measurement - Google Ads Help, Google. Checked November 22, 2026.
- About invalid traffic - Google Ads Help, Google. Checked November 22, 2026.
- Landing page - Google Ads Help, Google. Checked November 22, 2026.
- About Automated Local Services Ads lead credits - Local Services Help, Google. Checked November 22, 2026.
- Edit your industries, service areas, and job types - Local Services Help, Google. Checked November 22, 2026.
- Local Services Ads transition to Performance Max campaigns with pay-per-lead goals - Google Ads Help, Google. Checked November 22, 2026.
